Renting in Madison vs. Nearby Towns: How to Choose

Exterior of Timber Bluff Apartments, a Patriot Properties community in Madison, Wisconsin

Plenty of people who work in Madison don't live there. Sun Prairie, Middleton, Fitchburg, Waunakee, Oregon and Stoughton are all a short drive from the city, and each has its own downtown, parks and local businesses. This guide compares renting in Madison with renting in the surrounding Dane County towns, and covers what to check on a listing so you can make the call.

Every Patriot Properties city page links to the local government site, the chamber of commerce and live listings, so you can dig into any town below.

Renting in Madison

Madison is Wisconsin's capital, built on an isthmus between Lake Mendota and Lake Monona. Capitol Square, State Street, the UW–Madison campus, Henry Vilas Zoo, the UW Arboretum and Monona Terrace are among its best-known places.

Why renters pick Madison

  • You're close to the big employers. The university, UW Health, state government, American Family Insurance and Exact Sciences are all major Madison employers.
  • Transit. Metro Transit serves the city and many nearby communities, so living car-light is realistic in many neighborhoods.
  • Variety. Our Madison homes range from apartment communities on the east and west sides to smaller buildings in older neighborhoods. Examples include Liberty Valley Apartments and Timber Bluff Apartments.

What to weigh: parking and commute times differ a lot by neighborhood. Some buildings have garages or off-street lots, and others rely on street parking. Check each listing.

See our Madison apartments page or the live Madison listings.

The nearby towns at a glance

Sun Prairie (northeast)

Sun Prairie borders Madison to the northeast and is the area's largest suburb. It has a historic downtown and hosts the Sweet Corn Festival every August. U.S. 151 and Highway 19 run through the city, and Madison Metro provides local routes plus service into Madison. Major employers include QBE Insurance, Costco, Colony Brands and Milwaukee Tool. → Sun Prairie apartments · Our renter's guide to Sun Prairie

Middleton (west)

Middleton sits just west of Madison, with parks, trails and a walkable downtown. Employers named by the city and chamber include Electronic Theatre Controls, Capital Brewery and Spectrum Brands. West Towne Mall and west-side Madison are close by. → Middleton apartments

Fitchburg (south)

Fitchburg is on Madison's south side, with parks and trails and Metro Transit routes into the city. Major employers listed by the city include Sub-Zero Group, Promega and Thermo Fisher Scientific. Fitchburg is split among more than one school district, so check the city's schools page for the address you're considering. → Fitchburg apartments

Waunakee (north)

Waunakee is a village just north of Madison and home to the Patriot Properties office. Ripp Park, the downtown Main Street and the historic railroad depot are local landmarks, and Highway 19 connects the village to the interstate. → Waunakee apartments

Oregon (south)

Oregon is a village south of Madison with a downtown shopping district, village parks and community events promoted by the village and chamber. → Oregon apartments

Stoughton (southeast)

Stoughton is a city southeast of Madison with a historic downtown and an active Visit Stoughton program. Major employers include Stoughton Trailers and Stoughton Health. → Stoughton apartments

Five questions to help you decide

1. Where will you be every weekday?

Start with your commute. Map the drive (or bus ride) from each town to your workplace at the time you'd actually travel. Living in a nearby town can cut your commute if you work on that side of Madison, or add to it if you have to cross the isthmus.

2. Do you need transit, or will you drive?

If you rely on the bus, check Metro Transit routes for the exact address. Madison, Sun Prairie and Fitchburg have Metro service and routes reach other parts of the metro, but how often buses run varies by route.

3. What does the rent actually include?

Rent is only part of the monthly cost. Every listing says which utilities you pay. Some of our buildings include water, sewer, heat or trash, and others don't. Add those costs before you compare two apartments. Wisconsin rules require landlords to tell you when water, heat or electricity aren't included in rent.

4. Parking, storage and laundry

Garages, carports, off-street lots, storage units and in-unit or shared laundry all vary by building, and some carry an extra monthly charge. If any of these matter to you, filter for them first.

5. Pets

Pet rules are set for each property, so check the pet policy on the listing. Where pets are allowed, you can have up to 2 pets per home, with a $250 pet deposit and $40 per month pet rent for each pet. Aggressive breeds and breeds restricted by our insurance aren't allowed, and many listings set a dog size limit. Assistance animals are not pets and are not charged pet fees.

The application is the same everywhere

Whichever town you pick, applying with Patriot Properties works the same way:

  1. Find a home on our live listings.
  2. Tour it. Many homes offer self-guided tours with Bluetooth-enabled smart locks, or you can call (608) 849-6500 or text or call (608) 999-9775.
  3. Click Apply Now. Our listings show the requirements: income of at least 3 times the rent, a credit check, a criminal background check and rental history.

Bottom line

  • Pick Madison if you want to be close to the campus, downtown or the big Madison employers, or if you want the most transit options.
  • Pick a nearby town if you work on that side of the metro, or if a particular building has the parking, storage or layout you need.

Either way, compare what's included in rent, tour before you sign, and use the live listings for current prices.

Questions?

Our office is at 204 Moravian Valley Rd, Suite N, Waunakee, WI 53597, open Monday to Friday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Call (608) 849-6500 or text or call (608) 999-9775.

Ready to find your next home?

Browse available units across Wisconsin and Dubuque, Iowa. Call (608) 849-6500 with questions.

See available units →

Patriot Properties is an equal housing opportunity provider.

Previous
Previous

How to Request Maintenance and What Counts as an After-Hours Emergency

Next
Next

Moving to Sun Prairie, WI: A Renter's Guide